This year, I've been seeing a lot of people promoting the use of egg cartons for starting seeds. While I love the idea of re-using what would otherwise be (hopefully) recycled, they just don't work very well. I tried it last spring, and the results were overall, pretty disappointing:
1. The egg carton paper is too thick and acts as a wick, taking water away from the soil.
2. The egg pods are too small, and seedlings do not have enough room to grow healthy and strong before transplanting.
3. The egg carton paper is, again, too thick. You cannot just plant it into the ground and expect it to decompose and allow the seedling to flourish, and it is otherwise very difficult to get the seedling out of the egg pods.
(For a defense of the egg carton seed start project see the comments below. I posted my issues with this project elsewhere, and got a rebuttal - which someone intent on re-using their egg cartons may find very helpful)
This year, instead, I decided to try something completely new and just as recyclely:
Origami seed start pots!
Materials needed:
Scrap paper
Cupcake tray you don't plan on using for a while
Seeds
Soil
To make the cups, find detailed origami instructions (with charts and graphs!) here.
Next, place cups in cupcake tray, fill the cups with soil, place in the seed according to the packet's directions, add water and a few weeks later...
Since the scrap paper is pretty thin, you could theoretically just place the cups directly into the garden bed you intend them for. Though, it will probably be a good idea to cut a hole in the bottom (if one hasn't already developed) before planting.
Good gardening to you!
Egg Carton Defense:
ReplyDelete"I have used the egg cartons in the past and they have worked fine. I make sure they have plenty water. I cut them apart from each other, pop the bottom open part way about a week before they go in the ground. We did that with the Head Start... the first year I was there and
the kids had a great time!"